Notices
Automotive Discussion Automotive talk that is not technical can be posted here. Posts must address the general population.

Working with fiberglass?

Old 09-17-2008, 01:41 PM
  #1  
Danny@respecgarage
Thread Starter
 
RE-SPECGARAGE's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: www.respecgarage.com
Posts: 4,471
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
RE-SPECGARAGE RE-SPECGARAGE RE-SPECGARAGE RE-SPECGARAGE RE-SPECGARAGE RE-SPECGARAGE RE-SPECGARAGE RE-SPECGARAGE RE-SPECGARAGE RE-SPECGARAGE RE-SPECGARAGE
Default Working with fiberglass?

Does anyone on here work with fiberglass? I am thinking of making some side skirts for my car, but dont know in what direction I should start. I am a big fan of DIY jobs and would like to learn on how to come up with molds for repeat use and maybe resale if they come out good enough. Companies like shineauto in cali take an expensive sideskirt or bumper and replicate them using their own special resins. I want to be able to come up with something simple I could use in the garage and apply them to my cars.

I am looking for something that is highly durable, flexiable, and easy to work with.


Waiting for some constructive criticism,
Danny
RE-SPECGARAGE is offline  
Old 09-17-2008, 01:53 PM
  #2  
Slammedxpert
 
SortaFlush's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Virginia Beach
Posts: 6,825
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
SortaFlush SortaFlush SortaFlush SortaFlush SortaFlush SortaFlush SortaFlush SortaFlush SortaFlush SortaFlush SortaFlush
Default Re: Working with fiberglass?

You want my .02?



Good luck If you get serious, post some pics.
SortaFlush is offline  
Old 09-17-2008, 01:56 PM
  #3  
Logic is my religion
 
R. Danneskjöld's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2004
Posts: 3,434
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld
Default Re: Working with fiberglass?

You could cut a model out of foam, and use that to lay your cloth and resin on top of, later you should be able to cut or sand it away. The flex vs brittle is determined by how much and what kind of resin you use. All my experience with working fiberglass was on 46's in the Marines, but that's how I would attempt something like that.
R. Danneskjöld is offline  
Old 09-17-2008, 02:02 PM
  #4  
LickMyButthole
 
yeldak99's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Posts: 2,544
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
yeldak99 yeldak99 yeldak99 yeldak99 yeldak99 yeldak99 yeldak99 yeldak99 yeldak99 yeldak99 yeldak99
Default Re: Working with fiberglass?

YGPM
yeldak99 is offline  
Old 09-17-2008, 02:10 PM
  #5  
Dickbutt #peentip
 
Kris.Is.Foamin's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Virginia Beach
Posts: 10,256
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Kris.Is.Foamin Kris.Is.Foamin Kris.Is.Foamin Kris.Is.Foamin Kris.Is.Foamin Kris.Is.Foamin Kris.Is.Foamin Kris.Is.Foamin Kris.Is.Foamin Kris.Is.Foamin Kris.Is.Foamin
Default Re: Working with fiberglass?

I have minimal experience, and like benflagg said- make a foam model- but you will need to make an epoxy (or something similar) mold out of it (FG resin will eat foam). You could also use a stock sideskirt, and build on top of it- As to how many layers and of what fiberglass to actually use? You got me.
Kris.Is.Foamin is offline  
Old 09-17-2008, 02:51 PM
  #6  
Logic is my religion
 
R. Danneskjöld's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2004
Posts: 3,434
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld
Default Re: Working with fiberglass?

Originally Posted by Kris.is.awesome
I have minimal experience, and like benflagg said- make a foam model- but you will need to make an epoxy (or something similar) mold out of it (FG resin will eat foam). You could also use a stock sideskirt, and build on top of it- As to how many layers and of what fiberglass to actually use? You got me.
You can actually just put aluminum tape or foil over the foam, once you cut the foam away you should be able to peel away the foil tape.
R. Danneskjöld is offline  
Old 09-17-2008, 03:00 PM
  #7  
Registered member
 
RandomTask's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2004
Posts: 6,252
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
RandomTask RandomTask RandomTask RandomTask RandomTask RandomTask RandomTask RandomTask RandomTask RandomTask RandomTask
Default Re: Working with fiberglass?

Model it with foam, get as close as possible to what you want, even doing body work on the foam (yes, use bondo) Take expoxy and build a negative of your foam. Use that mold to make parts. Yes, its very time consuming.
RandomTask is offline  
Old 09-17-2008, 03:39 PM
  #8  
Racetracks
 
Fabrik8's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: How long is a piece of string?
Posts: 15,668
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Fabrik8 Fabrik8 Fabrik8 Fabrik8 Fabrik8 Fabrik8 Fabrik8 Fabrik8 Fabrik8 Fabrik8 Fabrik8
Default Re: Working with fiberglass?

I could write a small book on this topic. My screen name comes mostly from my composites work actually.

Ok, so where to start. I'm going to keep this somewhat general, but focus on what would work well for something like the sideskirts you want.
I'm writing this off the top of my head so the organization will suck, but that's OK.

First, some background and clarification on what's already been said.

A quick note on "special resins": The "special resins" that fiberglass companies use aren't made by them, they're made for them. Polymer chemistry isn't something you can just play with, some shop can't mix a bunch of resins together and come up with some new resin that works. Doesn't happen. It's possible to call up a resin supplier or manufacturer and get a resin tailored to the properties that you want, such as pot life (time before gel) exotherm, flexibility, toughness, etc. There are always tradeoffs obviously, and you can't have the best of all worlds for what you're doing. Most custom resins require huge min quantities, although there are a lot of really cool resins already on the market (like flex resin) that are available if you want to buy a drum of it, or at least 5 gallons for commonly available stuff.

Fiberglass: There are a lot of types of fiberglass on the market, all different based on weight (grams/m^2, or oz/yard, basically weight per area), weave type, and fiberglass type (don't worry about that part too much). So when someone says "make it out of fiberglass", that's not really saying anything. Briefly, heavier weights are generally thicker and will build up thickness per layer faster. There are plain (basket) weaves with big wide fiber bundles (called roving) that are very thick, fine weave fabrics with very good strength, and random fiber mats (chopped strand mat). The chopped strand mat is the cheapest, easiest to work with, and has the worst physical properties of anything you can buy. There are also specialty fabrics like biaxial and triaxial, which are just layers of (non-woven) bundles which alternate directions in each layer, kind of like the wood grain in plywood. There are many others, and many subtypes of the ones I've already listed, but I'll let you see what's out there.

Resins:
Polyester: The common "fiberglass resin" is polyester resin. This is the stuff that smells really bad (actually, I love that smell). It's fairly cheap, there are lots of kinds available, and special kinds for special uses. General purpose layup resins are usually garbage, so look for a premium layup resin at the bare minimum. The price difference is only a few bucks a gallon, if that. Never buy resin from Lowes or any place like that, it's crap and way overpriced. Shrinkage of up to a couple percent by volume. That could mean length or width or both, depending on the shape of the part. The amount of reinforcement (fiber to resin ratio), the cross sectional area (thickness of curing resin) and the cure time all affect the amount of shrinkage.

Vinylester: In between polyester and epoxy for price and performance. Not as easy to find as either, and I don't usually use it because I'm either going for cheap or strong, not in between. Chemically similar to polyester though, with a similar smell. Shrinkage not as bad as polyester.

Epoxy: Ah, the good stuff. Most expensive (and there is a HUGE price range) and the best physical properties. Mix ratio is critical usually, or the resin will never properly cure. There are some epoxy systems which are more forgiving than others, and some which can be physically tailored through different mix ratios (those are rare). So plan on a very accurate measuring or weighing system. Most epoxies don't like UV light, so they have to be painted, and epoxies usually don't take well to sanding (and especially not polishing). Shrinkage is negligible, and usually too small to measure.

Generally, for room temp cure composites (no ovens, post curing, etc.) you can save money and make molds out of polyester resin. It's easier to maintain them because of the ease of sanding and polishing, and polyester gel coat systems are a fraction of the price of epoxy gel coat systems. You'll use a lot of resin for the molds, so low price is good.
Gel coat is usually used as the outer surface of a mold, because it is easy to maintain and polish without exposing raw fibers, and it gives some thickness to prevent print-through. Oh, print through.. Print through is what happens when polyester resin shrinks during the cure, conforming to the fibers or fabric weave and leaving the weave texture visible through the surface of the part. I'm sure you've seen cheap fiberglass products that this is visible on. There are various things like surfacing veil that can be used to help that, but that's a mini-novel in itself.

Ok, so on to molds. Molds are a huge topic, and I'm going to make it short. Generally, molds are a lot of layers of fiberglass, and need to be sturdy. You don't want a mold's surface to flex while you're laying up a part in it, and you don't want it to crack while you're pulling a cured part out. So molds are usually pretty damn beefy. They're also usually braced with some type of stiffeners or structures to keep the whole mold from twisting or distorting depending on what it's resting on, etc. The easiest way to make a crooked part is to make it in a crooked mold..
Molds are usually made on a finished or semi-finished part (you can buff the mold before using needed) starting with gel coat against the part surface. Mold release goes first obviously, so it will actually come off. Gel coats are usually sprayed, but some can be brushed with OK results. After the gel coat, surfacing veil and a few layers of chopped strand mat go down to prevent print through. Once this is built up enough, the big reinforcements can go down, like woving roving or heavy cloth to build up stiffness and strength. Sometimes bulkers like coremat are used for the same purpose (cheap, fast buildup) with another layer or two of fiberglass over the top of that. Next the stiffeners go on, if necessary. MDF cut to shape works well, with intermittant pieces of fiberglass to secure the MDF to the mold.
All of those steps are done with curing in between, so there aren't big thickness curing at the same time which would lead to lots of shrinking (read: warping) and a lot of exotherm. Good molds take a loooong time, make no mistake. Don't forget buffing so your parts come out nice and easy.

That is the same process that any shop would do when copying an existing part. If you already have a part to make a mold from, it's that much easier.

Okay, so you want to make a part. You've put a lot of layers of mold release in your mold, so you part comes out. You can choose whether or not to use gel coat, and you can often skip that step if you won't need to do any sanding and the part will get painted. Your fabric choice will depend on what properties you want, strength, cost, etc, and you can research the tradeoffs on your own. So you put down a layer of fabric, apply resin with a brush or roller (there are special resin-proof paint rollers), put down another layer or two, and use a squeegee or ribbed roller to compact the fiberglass. When you have enough layers, you obviously let it cure. How many layers depends, again, on your choice of properties. Fiberglass is cheap, so a test piece isn't a bad idea. Whatever you're doing, it really helps to practice beforehand so you get a feel for what you're doing and how everything interacts.

So back a few steps.. You want to make a foam plug (pattern) for a side skirt. You have a few types of foam to work with, each (again) with its own properties. Rigid urethane foam (usually polyurethane) and isocyanate foam, each with many different types (polyisocyanate, etc) and different available densities, are really good to work with but not necessarily cheap. Polystyrene foam, which is what house insulating foam is, works OK and isn't nearly as nice to work with. It's attacked by polyester resin, because the solvent is pretty crazy (thats what gives it the smell). It's really cheap though. If you want to use polyester resin (and why not) you can cover the foam with epoxy and take the mold off of that, or make the mold with epoxy ($$$), or cover the foam with something else. If the part is simple, good quality clear packing take works really well usually. If you make the tape job look good, all you'll have to do is cover the tape with mold release before you make your mold.

Oh, and "flex vs brittle" mostly has to do with the type of resin, the part thickness, type of reinforcement, and the fiber to resin ratio. The resin itself is only part of the puzzle.



Ok I'm done for now, back to my homework.

Oh, and fuck Cliffs Notes, you can't learn anything that way. Read the whole post.
I typed it all out, you can read it all.

Last edited by Fabrik8; 09-17-2008 at 04:31 PM.
Fabrik8 is offline  
Old 09-17-2008, 06:15 PM
  #9  
Registered Member
 
ethan82000's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: hell
Posts: 945
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
ethan82000 has a reputation beyond reputeethan82000 has a reputation beyond reputeethan82000 has a reputation beyond reputeethan82000 has a reputation beyond reputeethan82000 has a reputation beyond reputeethan82000 has a reputation beyond reputeethan82000 has a reputation beyond reputeethan82000 has a reputation beyond reputeethan82000 has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Working with fiberglass?

Originally Posted by Fabrik8
I could write a small book on this topic. My screen name comes mostly from my composites work actually.

Ok, so where to start. I'm going to keep this somewhat general, but focus on what would work well for something like the sideskirts you want.
I'm writing this off the top of my head so the organization will suck, but that's OK.

First, some background and clarification on what's already been said.

A quick note on "special resins": The "special resins" that fiberglass companies use aren't made by them, they're made for them. Polymer chemistry isn't something you can just play with, some shop can't mix a bunch of resins together and come up with some new resin that works. Doesn't happen. It's possible to call up a resin supplier or manufacturer and get a resin tailored to the properties that you want, such as pot life (time before gel) exotherm, flexibility, toughness, etc. There are always tradeoffs obviously, and you can't have the best of all worlds for what you're doing. Most custom resins require huge min quantities, although there are a lot of really cool resins already on the market (like flex resin) that are available if you want to buy a drum of it, or at least 5 gallons for commonly available stuff.

Fiberglass: There are a lot of types of fiberglass on the market, all different based on weight (grams/m^2, or oz/yard, basically weight per area), weave type, and fiberglass type (don't worry about that part too much). So when someone says "make it out of fiberglass", that's not really saying anything. Briefly, heavier weights are generally thicker and will build up thickness per layer faster. There are plain (basket) weaves with big wide fiber bundles (called roving) that are very thick, fine weave fabrics with very good strength, and random fiber mats (chopped strand mat). The chopped strand mat is the cheapest, easiest to work with, and has the worst physical properties of anything you can buy. There are also specialty fabrics like biaxial and triaxial, which are just layers of (non-woven) bundles which alternate directions in each layer, kind of like the wood grain in plywood. There are many others, and many subtypes of the ones I've already listed, but I'll let you see what's out there.

Resins:
Polyester: The common "fiberglass resin" is polyester resin. This is the stuff that smells really bad (actually, I love that smell). It's fairly cheap, there are lots of kinds available, and special kinds for special uses. General purpose layup resins are usually garbage, so look for a premium layup resin at the bare minimum. The price difference is only a few bucks a gallon, if that. Never buy resin from Lowes or any place like that, it's crap and way overpriced. Shrinkage of up to a couple percent by volume. That could mean length or width or both, depending on the shape of the part. The amount of reinforcement (fiber to resin ratio), the cross sectional area (thickness of curing resin) and the cure time all affect the amount of shrinkage.

Vinylester: In between polyester and epoxy for price and performance. Not as easy to find as either, and I don't usually use it because I'm either going for cheap or strong, not in between. Chemically similar to polyester though, with a similar smell. Shrinkage not as bad as polyester.

Epoxy: Ah, the good stuff. Most expensive (and there is a HUGE price range) and the best physical properties. Mix ratio is critical usually, or the resin will never properly cure. There are some epoxy systems which are more forgiving than others, and some which can be physically tailored through different mix ratios (those are rare). So plan on a very accurate measuring or weighing system. Most epoxies don't like UV light, so they have to be painted, and epoxies usually don't take well to sanding (and especially not polishing). Shrinkage is negligible, and usually too small to measure.

Generally, for room temp cure composites (no ovens, post curing, etc.) you can save money and make molds out of polyester resin. It's easier to maintain them because of the ease of sanding and polishing, and polyester gel coat systems are a fraction of the price of epoxy gel coat systems. You'll use a lot of resin for the molds, so low price is good.
Gel coat is usually used as the outer surface of a mold, because it is easy to maintain and polish without exposing raw fibers, and it gives some thickness to prevent print-through. Oh, print through.. Print through is what happens when polyester resin shrinks during the cure, conforming to the fibers or fabric weave and leaving the weave texture visible through the surface of the part. I'm sure you've seen cheap fiberglass products that this is visible on. There are various things like surfacing veil that can be used to help that, but that's a mini-novel in itself.

Ok, so on to molds. Molds are a huge topic, and I'm going to make it short. Generally, molds are a lot of layers of fiberglass, and need to be sturdy. You don't want a mold's surface to flex while you're laying up a part in it, and you don't want it to crack while you're pulling a cured part out. So molds are usually pretty damn beefy. They're also usually braced with some type of stiffeners or structures to keep the whole mold from twisting or distorting depending on what it's resting on, etc. The easiest way to make a crooked part is to make it in a crooked mold..
Molds are usually made on a finished or semi-finished part (you can buff the mold before using needed) starting with gel coat against the part surface. Mold release goes first obviously, so it will actually come off. Gel coats are usually sprayed, but some can be brushed with OK results. After the gel coat, surfacing veil and a few layers of chopped strand mat go down to prevent print through. Once this is built up enough, the big reinforcements can go down, like woving roving or heavy cloth to build up stiffness and strength. Sometimes bulkers like coremat are used for the same purpose (cheap, fast buildup) with another layer or two of fiberglass over the top of that. Next the stiffeners go on, if necessary. MDF cut to shape works well, with intermittant pieces of fiberglass to secure the MDF to the mold.
All of those steps are done with curing in between, so there aren't big thickness curing at the same time which would lead to lots of shrinking (read: warping) and a lot of exotherm. Good molds take a loooong time, make no mistake. Don't forget buffing so your parts come out nice and easy.

That is the same process that any shop would do when copying an existing part. If you already have a part to make a mold from, it's that much easier.

Okay, so you want to make a part. You've put a lot of layers of mold release in your mold, so you part comes out. You can choose whether or not to use gel coat, and you can often skip that step if you won't need to do any sanding and the part will get painted. Your fabric choice will depend on what properties you want, strength, cost, etc, and you can research the tradeoffs on your own. So you put down a layer of fabric, apply resin with a brush or roller (there are special resin-proof paint rollers), put down another layer or two, and use a squeegee or ribbed roller to compact the fiberglass. When you have enough layers, you obviously let it cure. How many layers depends, again, on your choice of properties. Fiberglass is cheap, so a test piece isn't a bad idea. Whatever you're doing, it really helps to practice beforehand so you get a feel for what you're doing and how everything interacts.

So back a few steps.. You want to make a foam plug (pattern) for a side skirt. You have a few types of foam to work with, each (again) with its own properties. Rigid urethane foam (usually polyurethane) and isocyanate foam, each with many different types (polyisocyanate, etc) and different available densities, are really good to work with but not necessarily cheap. Polystyrene foam, which is what house insulating foam is, works OK and isn't nearly as nice to work with. It's attacked by polyester resin, because the solvent is pretty crazy (thats what gives it the smell). It's really cheap though. If you want to use polyester resin (and why not) you can cover the foam with epoxy and take the mold off of that, or make the mold with epoxy ($$$), or cover the foam with something else. If the part is simple, good quality clear packing take works really well usually. If you make the tape job look good, all you'll have to do is cover the tape with mold release before you make your mold.

Oh, and "flex vs brittle" mostly has to do with the type of resin, the part thickness, type of reinforcement, and the fiber to resin ratio. The resin itself is only part of the puzzle.



Ok I'm done for now, back to my homework.

Oh, and fuck Cliffs Notes, you can't learn anything that way. Read the whole post.
I typed it all out, you can read it all.
damn this man knows his shit....really good info..answered a few questions of mine too
ethan82000 is offline  
Old 09-17-2008, 06:33 PM
  #10  
Logic is my religion
 
R. Danneskjöld's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2004
Posts: 3,434
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld R. Danneskjöld
Default Re: Working with fiberglass?

Originally Posted by ethan82000
damn this man knows his shit....really good info..answered a few questions of mine too
Yep, this dude def knows his shit.
R. Danneskjöld is offline  

Quick Reply: Working with fiberglass?



All times are GMT -8. The time now is 05:39 PM.